Neenah, WI
(920) 720-2275

The full menu

25 specialty pizzas, 5 sauces, and a build-your-own with a sixth.

Every pizza on this page, specialty or built to order, is twelve inches. Pick a sauce first: it’s how the board is organised below. Prices are our own, published here as printed on our menu, and can change.

Before the pizza

Appetizers

  • Broken Sticks

    $7.00 Half | $13.00 Whole

    Bread sticks stuffed with cheese, topped with EVOO and Italian seasoning, served with a side of red sauce

  • Fire Sticks

    $8.00 Half | $16.00 Whole

    Bread sticks stuffed with jalapeno, bacon, and cheese, topped with green chili EVOO and Italian seasoning, served with a side of red sauce

  • Basil Sticks

    $8.00 Half | $15.00 Whole

    Bread sticks stuffed with basil and cheese, topped with EVOO and Italian seasoning, served with a side of red sauce

  • Pepperoni Sticks

    $8.00 Half | $15.00 Whole

    Bread sticks stuffed with pepperoni and cheese, topped with EVOO and Italian seasoning, served with a side of red sauce

  • Wood Fired Brussel Sprouts

    $10.00

    Brussel sprouts tossed with EVOO and garlic, finished with balsamic glaze and shredded parmesan. Add bacon $2, add goat cheese $3

  • Spin Dip Pizza

    $13.00

    Spinach artichoke dip spread on a pizza crust, topped with cheese and bread crumbs. Add roasted chicken $2

  • Garlic Strips

    $10.00

    Garlic butter, cheese, topped with Italian seasoning, served with a side of red sauce

Red Sauce

8 pizzas

  • Traditional Margherita

    $14.00

    Fresh mozzarella, basil, shredded parmesan, EVOO. Add sausage $2, add mushroom $2

  • The Classic

    $16.00

    House blend cheese, sausage, pepperoni, green pepper, red onion, Italian seasoning

  • The Select

    $16.00

    House blend cheese, sausage, pepperoni, roasted red pepper, red onion, black olive

  • Sgt. Pepper's

    $15.00

    House blend cheese, sausage, roasted red pepper, green pepper, jalapeno pepper

  • GardenVeggie

    $15.00

    House blend cheese, roasted red pepper, red onion, mushroom, basil, EVOO drizzle, finished with balsamic glaze. Add sausage $2

  • That's Life

    $15.00

    House blend cheese, calabrese salami, Italian seasoning, finished with arugula, balsamic glaze and shredded parmesan

  • Queen Bee

    $15.00

    Calabrese salami, fresh mozzarella, red pepper flakes, shredded parmesan, green chili oil drizzle, finished with a honey drizzle

  • Athena

    $16.00

    House blend cheese, gyro slices, feta cheese, tomato, spinach, finished with cilantro

White Sauce

5 pizzas

EVOO is extra virgin olive oil.

  • Roasted GoatVeggie

    $15.00

    House blend cheese, goat cheese, roasted red pepper, black olive. Add sausage $2

  • The Sweaty Pig

    $16.00

    House blend cheese, sausage, bacon, jalapeno pepper, green chili oil base sauce

  • Fun Guy

    $16.00

    House blend cheese, mushroom, goat cheese, finished with arugula and truffle oil drizzle. Add sausage $2

  • Italian

    $15.00

    House blend cheese, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, EVOO drizzle

  • Truffle by the Lake

    $16.00

    House blend cheese, fresh mozzarella, goat cheese, shredded parmesan, finished with arugula and truffle oil drizzle. Add chicken $2

Creamy Garlic Sauce

6 pizzas

  • Arya's ListVeggie

    $14.00

    House blend cheese, tomato, basil, EVOO drizzle, finished with balsamic glaze

  • Plantsylvania

    $14.00

    House blend cheese, green pepper, red onion, mushroom. Add chicken $2

  • Hailey's Comet

    $16.00

    House blend cheese, chicken, bacon, spinach, artichoke

  • Glazed & Confused

    $13.00

    House blend cheese, mushroom, finished with balsamic glaze

  • Duke Silver

    $16.00

    House blend cheese, bacon, goat cheese, tomato, finished with honey drizzle

  • Pete-za

    $17.00

    House blend cheese, chicken, bacon, sausage, roasted red pepper, Italian seasoning, pesto drizzle

BBQ Sauce

3 pizzas

  • Spicy BBQVeggie

    $14.00

    House blend cheese, red onion, jalapeno pepper, mushroom, finished with cilantro. Add chicken $2

  • Jawaiian

    $14.00

    House blend cheese, ham, pineapple, jalapeno pepper

  • Dixie Chicken

    $15.00

    House blend cheese, chicken, bacon, red onion, finished with cilantro

Pesto Sauce

3 pizzas

  • Magic Mushroom

    $15.00

    House blend cheese, chicken, bacon, mushroom

  • Broken PineVeggie

    $15.00

    House blend cheese, goat cheese, red onion, roasted red pepper, finished with balsamic glaze. Add sausage $2

  • Henry's 1st

    $17.00

    House blend cheese, chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted garlic, kalamata olives, finished with a balsamic glaze

Customize your own

From $12.00, 6 sauces to start from.

Base Price $12

All Customize Your Own pizzas and calzones come with house blend cheese. Twelve inch.

  1. Pizza or calzonePick the shape.
  2. Choose your sauceRed, white, bbq, garlic, pesto, or green chili oil.
  3. Choose your toppingsUp to five.
  4. Choose a finishOptional, $1 each. Arugula, balsamic glaze, cilantro, EVOO drizzle, green chili oil drizzle, or honey drizzle, added after the pizza is cooked.

Toppings

$1 each

Artichoke, banana peppers, black olives, green peppers, jalapeno peppers, red onion, roasted garlic, roasted red peppers

$2 each

Bacon, basil, chicken, kalamata olives, mushroom, pepperoni, pineapple, sausage

$3 each

Calabrese salami, feta cheese, fresh mozzarella, goat cheese, gyro slices, ham, prosciutto

For the little ones

Kids

  • The Sapling

    $8.00

    Eight inch pizza, house blend cheese, choice of sauce, up to two toppings, served with a choice of drink. Dine-in special only

  • Kraft Mac 'n' Cheese

    $8.00

    Served with applesauce and a choice of drink. Dine-in special only

To drink

Drinks

  • Fountain Soda

    $2.50

    Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Mr. Pibb, Mello Yello, Lemonade, Iced Tea, Raspberry Iced Tea. Free refills

  • Gourmet Bottled Soda

    $3.00

    Sun Drop, Sprecher Root Beer, Sprecher Cream, Sprecher Orange Dream, Sprecher Grape

Ready to order?

Call the shop and we’ll get it going. Prices above are the restaurant’s own published prices and can change.